The Panel
The coin is a 2007 penny. Two are using it

Cleveland at Baltimore
Taking Cleveland:Curtis, Joel, (C)
Taking Baltimore: Zach, Aaron, Phil, Andy, Nihar, Vivek

Pittsburgh at Cincinnati
Taking Pittsburgh:Zach, Aaron, Phil, Andy, Nihar, Vivek
Taking Cincinnati: Curtis, Joel,(C)

Kansas City at Philadelphia
Taking Philadelphia: Zach, Aaron, Phil, Andy, Nihar, Vivek, Curtis, Joel, (C)

Giants at Tampa Bay
Taking New York: Zach, Aaron, Phil, Andy, Nihar, Vivek, Curtis, Joel, (C)
Taking Tampa Bay:

Jacksonville at Houston
Taking Jacksonville: Andy, Curtis, Joel, (C)
Taking Houston:Zach, Aaron, Phil, Nihar, Vivek

Miami at San Diego
Taking San Diego:Zach, Aaron, Phil, Aaron, Andy, Nihar, Vivek, Curtis, Joel, (C)

San Francisco at Minnesota
Taking San Francisco: Aaron, Andy, Curtis, Joel, (C)
Taking Minnesota:Zach, Phil, Nihar, Vivek

Denver at Oakland
Taking Denver:Zach, Aaron, Phil, Nihar, Vivek
Taking Oakland:Andy, Curtis, Joel, (C)

Green Bay at St. Louis
Taking Green Bay:Zach, Aaron, Phil, Andy, Nihar, Vivek
Taking St. Louis:Curtis, Joel, (C)

Tennessee at Jets
Taking Tennessee:Aaron, Andy, Nihar, Curtis, Joel, (C)
Taking New York:Zach, Phil, Vivek

New Orleans at Buffalo
Taking New Orleans:Zach, Aaron, Phil, Andy, Nihar, Vivek, Curtis, Joel, (C)
Taking Buffalo:

Atlanta at New England
Taking Atlanta:Andy, Curtis, Joel, (C)
Taking New England: Zach, Aaron, Phil, Nihar, Vivek

Washington at Detroit
Taking Washington:Zach, Aaron, Andy, Nihar
Taking Detroit:Phil, Vivek, Curtis, Joel, (C)

Chicago at Seattle
Taking Chicago: Zach, Aaron, Phil, Nihar, Vivek
Taking Seattle: Andy, Curtis, Joel, (C)

Indianapolis at Arizona
Taking Indianapolis:Zach, Aaron, Phil, Andy, Nihar, Vivek
Taking Arizona:Curtis, Joel, (C)

Carolina at Dallas
Taking Carolina:Andy
Taking Dallas: Zach, Aaron, Phil Nihar, Vivek, Curtis, Joel, (C)