Monday, July 18, 2005

Gerut traded
A smart and good man was shown the door today as the Indians made their second trade of the season.
I was always skeptical about Jody Gerut. I liked his effort and enthusiasm, but wondered if his first season was a fluke. Jody led the Indians in 2003 with 22 homers and 75 runs batted in, but I had to ask if he was more than a bench player who had a great first year before pitchers adjusted to him.
My negativity about the Indians at that time was pretty strong -- I referred to Gerut as "Listache" to friends, thinking him little more than a one-year wonder.
His power numbers dropped last season,as the lefty managed 11 homers.
Towards the end of last season, he suffered a major injury and missed the first several weeks of 2005.
He leaves the team hitting .275, but has played only occasionally and has not hit for any power (one homer). While originally critical of Gerut, I recently became one of his biggest supporters. This happened when I realized the alternative to Gerut was Casey Blake.
Good luck with the Cubs, Jody.
---
Gerut's replacement is Jason Dubois, who is hitting .239 with seven homers. Like Blake, he is a right handed hitter. He has driven in 22 runs, just seven fewer than the Indians starter, but in far fewer games.
Indians GM Mark Shapiro is said to be high on Dubois because of his strong run production in the minor leagues.
The deal means that the Indians bench consists of right handed utility man Jose Hernandez, switch-hitting infielder Brandon Phillips, catcher and switch-hitter Josh Bard, and Dubois.
Of course, Dubois could come in and start in right, but that would mean Blake or Boone to the bench, which is something the Indians have refused to accept so far.
---
Can someone explain to me how Laz Diaz, who's the home plate umpire, has a better view of a play at first than the first base umpire, Dana DeMuth? Lou Pinella's outburst was hilarious, but completely justified.

2 Comments:

At 8:07 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

I can't explain Gerut's 22 homers in '03. I also don't think he's a slap hitter who is going to manage just single digits in homers every year.
Gerut finished '03 with a .279 average, which is probably the type of hitter he is going to be. Gerut will be an asset no matter where he goes because he understands how to play the game. As he gets older, he is going to be one heck of a wise veteran for younger players to learn from, even if he isn't much more than a decent player.
I admire Gerut because he was never considered a top prospect. The Rockies dumped he and Josh Bard for Jacob Cruz. Gerut simply worked hard to get where he is and makes the most of what I consider limited athletic ability (as far as the majors are concerned).
He could have very easily topped out as a minor-league lifer, but he persevered. Best of luck to him in Chicago, especially since he is going to the Chicago team I can actually stand.

 
At 8:16 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

This move baffles me. We just traded Jody Gerut for another casey blake. Like we need another! Once again, just like the deal with ludwig, we effectively weakened our bench and have no stability if there is an injury. Christ. . .

Love,
your brother

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home