Vitamin Z's Magnificent 7--Top Indians starting pitchers, 1986-present
From when I started following baseball intensely, when I was six years old.

1. Bartolo Colon
2. Dennis Martinez
3. Orel Hersheiser
4. Charles Nagy
5. Greg Swindell
6. C.C Sabathia
7. Tom Candiotti

Shows how thin the Indians pitching has been over the past 18 years, huh? Martinez and Hersheiser will always have a high spot with me due to their pitching in 1995.
But Colon, when he was on, was unhittable. His eight-inning performance in game one was the best pitched postseason game by an Indian, something that has been forgotten because the Tribe lost the series.